A Second Life

This little book by Alastair Sooke, passed over by so many during the ‘exit through the gift shop’ moment at Tate Modern, when Matisse’s exuberant cut-outs are still imprinted on the mind’s eye (almost literally, such is the power of his later huge works) in favour of posters, postcards and more weighty tomes too, is a good read.

I can’t let you leave the gift shop without pointing out the irony of so many flat and reasonably good reproductions of Matisse’s cut-outs being offered up for sale, given the artist’s own obvious disappointment in how his coloured papers seemed in reproduction. He was disappointed in Jazz in book form. I think although he hit the drawing-pin on the head because he was so aware that the cut-outs lost something without the physical presence of the papers, as the way the light reflects off the surfaces, the nature of the edges (cut or torn, neat or bearing the pinholes of previous sitings)  and surprisingly its thickness, perhaps this quality most of all, because we so need to see the papers being blown by air currents (or at least believing that they could still be repositioned) to understand the tension and power of these last, great paintings. They just work. Because they are physical things, like the paintings they are and the sculptures Matisse invoked when he described his scissors as carving colour directly. Teasingly, there is a 50-page photo essay of cutouts on his studio/apartment walls in the official catalogue (itself packed with essays that are  informative, necessarily discursive and helpful) that just makes me wish (in a way) that the exhibition cut-outs could have been taken out of their frames and pinned to the walls of the Tate Modern galleries. It is already so good to see the The Snail and Memory of Oceania together again after 60 years. It would have been extraordinary to have seen them pinned directly onto the walls again. It would have been a visceral pleasure to have seen why Christian Zervos (this from Sooke’s book) wrote in 1949: “I refuse to consider these paper cut-outs as an artistic event … I will say more: all these paper jokes are so unworthy of Matisse that there is no point talking about them … At most they could be used to decorate textiles or wallpaper.” Because we see them as being ‘by the master’ in their elegant frames on the gallery wall, some of the power of the work to have the “decisiveness of a slap” (Matisse said about that good drawing should possess this quality) might have been lost.

In his book, Sooke does go on to point out (as Spurling did) that the influence of growing up in the textiles town of Bohain was a benign one, which gives his cut-outs extra poignancy. He is very good on the rivalry with Picasso and the effect of Matisse’s debilitating physical state. The pictorial success of his obsession with movement and vibrancy comes from hard work and a longing for such physicality that was now beyond him.

I do like Alastair Sooke for allowing his enthusiasm for the wall-works (and of course the Chapel of the Rosary) to be evident in his writing. He describes the cut-outs with perceptive and simple clarity.

One final thing and on the day that Abu Hamza has been found guilty in the US,  and when Lawrence Whitehouse, who lost his wife in the kidnapping that Hamza was convicted for organising simply said (on the Today programme) that he was pleased that Hamza couldn’t send any more incendiary messages and talked about the harm he has done to the Islamic community, what a joy to hear Sooke telling us how Matisse wanted his Christian chapel to be – I can’t think of a more healing example in art:

“Matisse wanted his chapel to be a place where people could leave their burdens behind – ‘as Muslims leave the dust of the streets on the soles of the sandals lined up at the door of a mosque’.  How striking that in this analogy Matisse evoked Islam rather than Chrisitanity.”

This seems to me to at once reassure us that Matisse is a deep and sensitive thinker and that it is how things should be.




3 thoughts on “A Second Life

  1. Thank you Jonathan – I saw Matisse’s cutouts exhibition last week and found the only word I could think of was ‘JOYOUS’. When I saw the old photos, though, I also felt the cut outs put into frames lost their freedom.

    Good to hear from you – you are brilliant with words.

    Just to tell you (not for everyone) – I did get a portrait accepted into the annual exhibition of the Royal Society of Portrait Painters this year – I painted Nicolas de Stael from a small black and white photograph in the book I have of his paintings – sadly written in french! Because it was de Stael I had to use a palette knife! As you probably remember I paint under my maiden name – P.L.Wright

    Date: Tue, 20 May 2014 19:51:17 +0000 To: pencordle@hotmail.com

  2. Have just returned home this evening after seeing the Matisse Cut Outs.  Sorry to miss your blog before I went otherwise would have picked up Sooke’s book (saw it at the tills).  I was very inspired by the work and suddenly saw what he was trying to do.  I agree with your comments about the reproduction of the work – the originals with their pin marks and ‘made’ look was so exciting. Would love to have seen the paper fluttering slightly.  Lots to think about.

    Susan  Sent: Tuesday, 20 May 2014, 20:51 Subject: [New post] A Second Life   WordPress.com jonathanellisart posted: “This little book by Alastair Sooke, passed over by so many during the ‘exit through the gift shop’ moment at Tate Modern, when Matisse’s exuberant cut-outs are still imprinted on the mind’s eye (almost literally, such is the power of his later huge works)”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s